Where — and why — is agroforestry hiding?
A clear solution to climate change is being largely overlooked
This article is part of a Landscape Newsseries on agroforestry, published in partnership with World Agroforestry (ICRAF) in conjunction with the 4th World Congress on Agroforestry.
By Gabrielle Lipton
Margaret Muchanga used to get just one cup of milk per day from her cow. Her fields, when tilled, could give her about five to eight bags of maize. To support her family, this wasn’t enough.
As she sat onstage at the 4th World Congress on Agroforestry in Montpellier, France, in May, she smiled as a short documentary narrating her life in Kenya’s Mt Elgon region showed how planting trees on her farmland changed her life. That single cup turned into 1.5 litres, and those bags increased in number to 25. She could pay for health insurance and for her children’s education. When the weather acted unpredictably, she didn’t worry that she would be left in dire straits.
Agroforestry, a land-management system that couples the growth of trees and shrubs with crops and pasture, has been scientifically proven time and again to have a multitude of benefits: improved soil health, crop yields, resilience to climate change, biodiversity and household incomes. Yet, for all the many ways it can help households, communities and companies shield themselves and prosper in the face of climate change, it’s almost entirely neglected in national and international policy. When it is recognized, it’s hardly in a substantial way.
According to Chirstian Dupraz, chair of the scientific committee of the French Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA), part of the problem is that agroforested landscapes are immensely complex. They can come in many forms: alley cropping, contour hedgerows, forest farming, home gardens, multistory planting, silvopasture. They raise questions: Should they be organic? Should they be tilled? What kinds of seeding should they use? And they require research to know which tree species will help best, or even help at all.
Agroforestry also means farmers must take risks, particularly financially, as economic returns on investment in trees can take up to a few years while requiring more money to be spent on maintenance in the meantime.
Its proponents say subsidies could help it spread. However, if governments are going to begin handing out money to support this, its benefits need to be measured on a scale far larger than small farms like Muchanga’s. Countries need to know how agroforestry is helping to improve their economies and reduce their greenhouse gases.
In this respect, measuring and reporting greenhouse gases under the guidelines of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) has the potential to be the stage for agroforestry’s magic. The good news is that, according to research done by Todd Rosenstock, an agroecologist at World Agroforestry (ICRAF), 40% of 147 countries specifically mention ‘agroforestry’ as a solution for climate change in their Nationally Determined Contributions to the UNFCCC’s targets, including 70% of African countries.
However, ‘agroforestry falls victim to UNFCCC reporting requirements’, he said at the Congress.
Because it is not disaggregated from other land-based mitigation methods, there is no way to know the specifics of agroforestry within a country in regards to its scale and its contributions to reduced emissions.
‘This has big ramifications for the way those documents get used’, said Rosenstock, meaning that the positive effects of agroforestry are essentially hidden.
And because it is ‘homeless’ in most governments, often cutting across ministries such as Agriculture, Environment and Finance, it receives even less attention.
Agroforestry, however, could soon receive a boost in recognition. On 26 May, the UN Decade of Family Farming was declared, following on from the General Assembly’s adoption of the UN Decade of Ecosystem Restoration on 1 March. Maria Helena Semedo, deputy director-general of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), said that her organization will work closely with partners to include agroforestry in the awareness-raising efforts that will run throughout the 10 years of each focus area.
Agroforestry is in a transition phase, said INRA’s President Managing Director Philippe Mauguin, and more economic research needs to be put into it. One of its major potentials, he said, is to act as a ‘lever’ to restore biodiversity. According to FAO, agroforested landscapes can have 50–80% of the biodiversity levels found in natural forests. In light of the new Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services’ report finding that 1 million species are at risk of extinction, agroforestry’s innate inclusivity of a variety of plants and wildlife shines bright.
In the Sahel region of Africa, for instance, agroforestry parklands ‘really look like forests’, said Cheikh Mbow, executive director of scientific capacity-building organization START, so much so that these parks will be classified as ‘forest’ under FAO standards by 2020. In the last 30 years, woody foliage has been working particularly well, he said, helping combat the ‘paradox of deforestation’ in Africa: deforestation is more prevalent in humid but populated areas, while sparsely inhabited drylands often see an increase in forest cover.
Timber, rubber, cashew, avocado, mango and cocoa plants are thriving in Sahelian agroforestry systems, he said, and oils from agroforestry biomass can be used in biofuels and energy resources. Highlighting agroforestry’s contributions to nutrition and energy can, and should, help in advocating for more policy around agroforestry in the region.
Similarly, ICRAF’s Kiros Hadgu, together with co-editors from Oregon State University (OSU), JIRCAS, WeForest and Mekelle University, will soon publish a book on Climate-Smart Agriculture: Enhancing Agricultural Systems, Landscapes and Livelihoods in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). He said that in order to scale agroforestry across the region, efforts must start small, i.e., to lookat nature of agriculture within each different local contexts and scales.
“Limited understanding of and access to climate-smart, multifunctional and locallyproven knowledge and practices in SSA contributed to chronically stagnant and highly vulnerable agriculture,” he said. “Consequently, resilience of ecosystems, agricultural systems and livelihoods has been declining and reached to a stagethat can no longer accommodate the growing demands for food, fuel and income of the increasing population in the region, and particularly in Ethiopia.”
In his book, he’sput together a guide for examining local problems, demands and spatial contexts, and thendetermining which technologies, strategies and social factors can be appliedat appropriate local contexts. In the end, this stretches agroforestry into climate-smart practice asa whole which can sustainably address priority issues in SSA including agriculture, soil, water, biodiversity, a variety of forest and non-forest ecosystems, rural energy, socioeconomics, gender and policy.
Many participants at the Congress laid out recommendations for increasing the use of agroforestry in global systems. Semedo said there are four elements needed.
- Communities need secure land tenure in order to be willing to invest their time and resources in planting trees.
- Policies are needed to regulate how farmers obtain seeds, seedlings and clones for a wide range of trees.
- Policies must recognize agroforestry as an attractive option for boosting agriculture, as opposed to chemical fertilizers or other ways that can potentially harm nature.
- Smallholders need more participation in markets in order to ensure their businesses develop in a just and fair manner.
Rosenstock also offered four recommendations for better inclusion of agroforestry in international policy.
- Create guidelines for land representation to help transparency in reporting on agroforestry.
- Delve into the ‘grey’ literature for insights into a higher level of regional/geographic specificity.
- Conduct more mapping of agroforestry landscapes.
- Conduct studies on institutional best practices and enabling environments for agroforestry so that more countries can learn how it’s most easily and effectively applied.
This information, he said, can then be collated as the basis for more proposals and policies around agroforestry and garner more funding; funding that will, in turn, render more profits. In the words of Dupraz: ‘Get rich, plant a tree’.
World Agroforestry (ICRAF) is a centre of science and development excellence that harnesses the benefits of trees for people and the environment. Leveraging the world’s largest repository of agroforestry science and information, we develop knowledge practices, from farmers’ fields to the global sphere, to ensure food security and environmental sustainability. ICRAF is one of the 15 members of the CGIAR, a global research partnership for a food-secure future. We thank all donors who support research in development through their contributions to the CGIAR Fund.